City’s Squad Questions Take Centre Stage Amid Trafford, Ake and Ortega Uncertainty
Recruitment Shifts and Mid Season Anxiety
Manchester City stand on unfamiliar ground. With Txiki Begiristain gone, the carefully engineered stability of the club’s recruitment model has entered a period of transition. The Daily Mail suggest that this phase may only “settle into a recognised pattern” after several windows, with new figure Hugo Viana potentially more inclined to intervene mid campaign. One source quoted in the piece remarked, “it feels like Viana wants to move faster”, though any bold reshaping will always be tempered by Pep Guardiola’s preference for continuity.
Photo IMAGO
Advertisement
Last season’s mid winter business was described as “an exceptional circumstance”, and City remain cautious about disrupting a squad still expected to compete on multiple fronts. Yet the shadows of future decisions loom across the training ground, particularly around three names attracting significant attention.
Trafford Interest Raises Selection Questions
The Daily Mail note that James Trafford continues to be a topic of debate. Despite limited minutes, there is a belief internally that he “doesn’t necessarily need regular games” to make the World Cup squad as Thomas Tuchel’s third choice. His development has been monitored meticulously, and City recognise the importance of maintaining a long term pathway for him.
Photo IMAGO
Advertisement
Ortega’s Role and Outside Approaches
Stefan Ortega has already faced external pressure. According to the report, he “turned down approaches from Fenerbahce, Sunderland and Burnley over the summer”, signalling his willingness to compete for minutes rather than seek a comfortable exit. It feels “inconceivable that both goalkeepers will leave”, yet the hierarchy must confront the reality that each window brings new suitors. A decision on who will remain as trusted deputy to Donnarumma may become unavoidable.
Photo IMAGO
Ake’s Frustration Shapes January Narrative
Nathan Ake stands at the heart of the most sensitive dilemma. Despite Ronald Koeman insisting that Ake “is going to the World Cup regardless of minutes”, the defender’s frustration is unmistakable. With only one Premier League start this season, the Dutch international has slipped down the order after persistent injuries. The Daily Mail describe him as “one to watch come January”, and his close relationship with Guardiola complicates the story further. As one figure put it, “if Ake communicates that the time has come, the manager will respect that”.
Photo IMAGO
Advertisement
City also have “at least two others” evaluating their situations, setting the stage for a potentially lively winter window.
Our View – EPL Index Analysis
City fans will read this report with a mix of curiosity and mild apprehension. The departures of long serving architects behind the scenes rarely pass without consequence, and the idea of a shifting recruitment structure naturally prompts questions. Supporters have grown accustomed to cohesion from top to bottom, and the suggestion that Hugo Viana may be more proactive will divide opinion. Some will welcome the energy, others will worry about disruption during a title push.
The situations involving Trafford, Ortega and Ake feel particularly significant. From a supporter’s point of view, the idea of losing both keepers at once is simply unrealistic, especially with Guardiola valuing stability in defensive positions. Most fans see Ortega as the ideal backup, calm on the ball and increasingly trusted, while Trafford remains an investment for the next chapter. The line from the Daily Mail that Trafford “doesn’t necessarily need regular games” fits the belief that his ceiling is high enough to justify patience.
Advertisement
Ake is where emotions shift. Fans know how important he has been in big games, especially in City’s treble winning season. Seeing him limited to one league start is genuinely surprising. Many would understand his frustration, but losing him mid season would feel like a backward step unless the club line up a replacement of similar tactical intelligence. With Guardiola’s respect for Ake well documented, supporters trust that any decision will be made collaboratively and with fairness.
