Inside Mike Tomlin’s decision to walk away from Steelers

As only the most loyal, or maybe the most unhappy, fans remained seated in the vivid yellow rows of Acrisure Stadium on a deflating, icy evening, Mike Tomlin departed the field for the final time as head coach of the Pittsburgh Steelers shortly after 11 p.m. on Monday night.

A week prior, he had celebrated with exuberance, pounding his chest and blowing kisses as he exited triumphantly, reveling in an AFC North championship before an ecstatic audience. A miraculous fourth quarter led by quarterback Aaron Rodgers and a missed field goal attempt by the Baltimore Ravens revived Tomlin’s 2025 Steelers, granting them a chance to overcome a streak of postseason disappointments.

However, that optimism and elation were vanished following a tightly contested wild-card matchup that cascaded into a 30-6 rout against the Houston Texans. Tomlin navigated through clusters of dazed Pittsburgh players and staff, past benches and heaters, making his way down the steps to the tunnel, with Rodgers closely following.

Cameron Heyward was surrounded by a gaggle of reporters and cameras at his locker, responding to inquiries as emotional tremors shook his voice. Tomlin stood a few feet away from the crowd, intently observing the player he had drafted in the first round 15 years ago.

«[Fans] don’t realize the effort Mike T puts into this,» Heyward defended his coach that night. «They have no idea how he meticulously prepares every individual. They are oblivious to the endless nights he spends studying film. Coaches can only accomplish so much; players must perform better. In those decisive instances, players need to step up.»

After about 15 seconds, Tomlin broke his stare, turned, and exited the locker room alone, passing through the black double doors for the last time as head coach just before midnight.

---

The dawning of honesty (Tuesday, 5:30 a.m. to noon)

Shortly after 5:30 the following morning, Tomlin arrived at the Steelers’ training facility in his light blue Ford Bronco. Though he recognized the day would culminate uniquely in his career, it commenced as it always did, with an early morning arrival.

Among the slated meetings was Tomlin’s standard mid-morning end-of-season discussion with team president Art Rooney II. The 73-year-old executive expected Tomlin to share his vision for how he and the organization would advance together.

However, Tomlin envisioned a different future for the franchise: one that did not include him. While it wasn’t the discussion Rooney expected, he was not shocked by Tomlin’s conclusion.

«I was not surprised, but I didn’t foresee that outcome yesterday either,» Rooney stated on Wednesday. «When you reach this phase in your career, as he noted himself, he was closer to the end than to the start, so that was anticipated. … I was definitely looking forward to taking another shot with Mike next year. That’s what I anticipated discussing yesterday, but clearly, it took a different course.»

The meeting with Rooney lasted no longer than 20 minutes, concluding several hours before Tomlin was set to meet with the team.

Make your Super Bowl LX prop picks for FREE! Create a group and invite your friends and family to play. FREE to play

By noon, a select few were aware that Tomlin would share the news with the players during the 2 p.m. meeting, including his family, Rooney, and general manager Omar Khan. Before the meeting, Tomlin gathered with spokesperson Burt Lauten to review specifics. Statements from Rooney and Tomlin were released after the meeting.

With the organization unknowingly shifting beneath their feet, those present continued with their usual routines. The scouting department held discussions to evaluate candidates for future contracts, staff members moved in and out of the cafeteria for lunch, and players came in for their end-of-season physicals and to clear out their lockers. They collected large trash bags from the equipment room to sort through the remains of the season.

Rodgers, still publicly uncertain about his future, sifted through keepsakes from his Pittsburgh chapter at his corner locker, smiling as he perused personal cards and messages. Various staff, media individuals, and players approached him in an impromptu, staggered receiving line, some offering simple words of gratitude, while others brought jerseys, a sharpie, and requests.

Offensive lineman Andrus Peat approached with a black Rodgers jersey still bearing its tag. Rodgers waved the store-bought item aside and pulled out what seemed like a white, game-worn jersey from a bag in his locker. He retrieved a silver sharpie from the equipment room and inscribed a message to Peat on the black No. 8.

Elsewhere in the locker room, T.J. Watt, Miles Killebrew, and Alex Highsmith lingered in another corner by Watt’s locker, chatting as they passed the time before the meeting. Tight ends Pat Freiermuth and Jonnu Smith embraced and exchanged jerseys, while quarterback Will Howard and linebacker Jack Sawyer shared light-hearted banter in the equipment room.

The atmosphere was somber, as is often the case following a disappointing and unsatisfactory conclusion to the season, yet with seven consecutive postseason defeats — six of which were in the wild-card round — it was a familiar sentiment.

A few players engaged with reporters, discussing the wild-card defeat, their personal growth throughout the season, and the significance of Tomlin as their leader.

«One of the best coaches I’ve ever had, probably the best,» Freiermuth expressed. «In my view, his message remains fresh. I believe in him.»

---

The ‘Game of Thrones’ farewell (Tuesday, 2 p.m.)

A coach who for nearly two decades prioritized routine was adhering to his own, providing no indication he was about to stun the NFL community within a modest team meeting space.

He entered through the door at 2 p.m. Tuesday, attired in his signature Steelers cap and long-sleeve shirt. The room was filled with around 100 players, coaches, and support staff. Against the backdrop of gold walls, a whiteboard, and a projector, Tomlin relayed familiar themes regarding a season that concluded prematurely and the remarkable effort and commitment his team exhibited. He spoke of ramifications and accountability.

Yet, Tomlin couldn’t conceal his shifting demeanor for long: His delivery was slightly more restrained than his usual animated self, per two team sources in attendance. The players and coaches remained oblivious to the unexpected path Tomlin was about to embark on.

Tomlin is an exceptional wordsmith, a result of his mother’s passion for education during his upbringing in Hampton, Virginia — notably an obsession with the World Book Encyclopedia. Therefore, it’s unsurprising that Tomlin’s remarks resonated with those in attendance differently, each recalling distinct elements.

You deserve better, and right now I can’t deliver, one senior team source recalled Tomlin articulating.

Someone else has to move the franchise forward, another source remembered.

Inside Mike Tomlin’s last day as Steelers coach
&#8226 How Bears, Williams became offensive juggernaut
&#8226 Favorite Mike Vrabel story? We have ‘em
&#8226 Next Gen Stats: Stafford, Allen, more
&#8226 How players prepare for cold-weather games

And another, simply: It’s best that I step down.

A coaching source recollected Tomlin referencing the «Game of Thrones» series to illustrate the cutthroat dynamics of coaching — and winning — in the NFL.

«The expressions on the faces of coaches and players spoke one word — ‘What?!'» said a team source regarding the unfolding moment. «It was utterly silent.»

The conclusion was sudden. Tomlin exited to a standing ovation, then assumed his customary position after every meeting — standing at the door, greeting individuals as they departed. He engaged in high-fives, hugs, and then walked away, the only semblance of normalcy for a franchise that now has to redefine what that signifies.

On his final day, Tomlin embraced the accountability. Those present were aware that was largely unwarranted, even absurd.

«He didn’t need to say that. But that’s Mike,» a coaching source remarked. «He will always take responsibility when the ultimate objective isn’t achieved, although it’s evident to the players there’s so much more, and Mike maximized the team’s potential.»

The meeting lasted less than half an hour, and by 2:30 p.m., players were leaving the practice facility parking area.

Just two hours later, shortly before 4:30 p.m., a light blue Ford Bronco pulled out of the gates and traveled down Water Street.

---

The future: ‘Off the couch’

Amid the raw emotion of the meeting was a line spoken by Tomlin during his formal farewell that resonated with one coaching source: «I’m not interested in coaching anyone else’s team right now,» the source recounted Tomlin stating in that 2 p.m. session.

This was interpreted by the source to indicate that Tomlin will likely not coach in 2026 and may genuinely take an extended hiatus, yet has left a slight opening for a future return.

Long-snapper Christian Kuntz, a Pittsburgh native, also interpreted Tomlin’s comments as him not planning to be on another sideline anytime soon. «He did emphasize he was stepping down and had no intentions of coaching anyone else but the guys he was currently focused on,» Kuntz mentioned on his podcast Thursday.

«A few» NFL teams reached out to Tomlin regarding potential opportunities in the 2026 offseason, according to a source, but it was clearly communicated that he is not coaching next season.

Nonetheless, Tomlin understands the advantage of a career reset that can lead to a second act. He frequently discusses this concept, the coaching source adds.

«He often mentions ‘getting off the couch,’ when coaches take a break from the game and return with fresh insights, as ‘different versions’ of themselves,» the source stated. «He enjoys studying football, so I could foresee him coming back in that capacity. I’m just uncertain of the timing, and it could be quite a while. He seems to genuinely require a break.»

Speculations about Tomlin’s necessity for a breather had been surfacing for weeks, and a source close to him clarified that Tomlin’s choice to step back was a well-considered one. This outcome had likely been anticipated long before the playoff elimination by Houston, indicated the source, who believed that discussions about a departure started over the summer. His decision to inform the team merely 15 hours post-Monday night’s game underscores that reality.

«What else is left to pursue?» the source speculated concerning Tomlin’s mindset throughout this process. «He’s been committed for nearly two decades. His children have all grown up. It’s just a moment for renewal.»

During his Wednesday press conference, Rooney mentioned that Tomlin conveyed his desire to spend additional time with his family.

«Mike expressed that he did not foresee coaching in the near future,» Rooney remarked. «I believe he wishes to spend time with his family and engage in activities he has been unable to do for many years. If opportunities arise (to coach again), we will address them when they do, but for now that doesn’t seem to be on his agenda.»

What looms significant in Tomlin’s future is whether he seriously considers offers from television networks seeking the next charismatic star. Tomlin, known for his quick wit and presentation, has reportedly received informal offers from several networks, according to an industry insider. What exactly lies ahead for Tomlin is uncertain, but that option will remain available, and it’s expected that he will at least contemplate it.

«Provided he has something to keep his competitive spirit alive,» the insider said.

Fan dissatisfaction or feelings of being undervalued did not play any role in the decision, numerous sources close to Tomlin insisted. «His primary concern has always been the welfare of his players, coaches, and Rooney,» stated one of the sources. «He has never been able to satisfy the fans, not from the beginning.»

Reid | Yates | Miller
• Rankings: Kiper | Miller | Reid | Yates
• Best by position | Draft order | More

And if 2027 or 2028 marks Tomlin’s readiness to coach at the NFL level again, prospective teams will be elated — as will coaching agents who are aware that the market will potentially reset significantly.

The Steelers hold his contractual rights for one more season, along with an option year, indicating the team would be entitled to draft compensation via trade, akin to the arrangement the New Orleans Saints had when trading Sean Payton to Denver in 2023, receiving first- and second-round picks as part of that deal.

Tomlin could then opt for a model that suits him — whether it entails a complete rebuild that he can tailor to his preferences, or inheriting a predecessor’s ready-made roster, similar to the Pittsburgh role he took over from Hall of Fame coach Bill Cowher in 2007.

In the past, Tomlin has conveyed to those close to him that he would relish the opportunity to construct a team from the ground up, even possibly over the chance to take over an established roster with existing infrastructure.

---

The consequences: A franchise at a pivotal juncture

Even with Tomlin’s departure, the ownership’s expectations remain unchanged. To Rooney, a new coach does not imply that the franchise will undergo an entire rebuild — even if the roster resembles more of a rehabilitation project than a turnkey squad.

«I’m unsure why one would waste a year of their life not attempting to contend,» Rooney stated. «Your roster is what it is. It evolves each year. Therefore, you address what you have every year, attempting to position yourself to compete every month. Occasionally you have the right players, sometimes you don’t, but the intention is to try every year.»

The roster, however, is particularly thin at the quarterback position as the Steelers approach the offseason.

«We haven’t had [a quarterback] in five years,» a team source noted.

And while the Steelers had two future Hall of Famers at the position during that span, both were at the twilight of their careers. Ben Roethlisberger retired after the 2021 season, while Rodgers, 42, may have just completed his final season in 2025.

Between Roethlisberger and Rodgers, the Steelers attempted to identify their next franchise signal-caller from a disorganized group including Kenny Pickett, Mitchell Trubisky, Mason Rudolph, Russell Wilson, and Justin Fields. None proved up to the task, leading to the Steelers signing Rodgers to a one-year contract in June 2025.

This places the Steelers in a familiar position they have faced each offseason since Roethlisberger’s retirement in January 2022: on the lookout for a starting quarterback. Parallel to that period, the Steelers are aiming for a new quarterback at a particularly inopportune time. Not only is the 2026 quarterback draft class anticipated to feature fewer immediate starter options than initially hoped, but the free agent and trade prospects seem to be lacking as well.

The incoming head coach will need to tackle quarterback dilemmas and other roster challenges as well.

The Steelers require another wide receiver to complement DK Metcalf, a highly talented, yet somewhat volatile star who was suspended for the last two games of the season following an incident with a Detroit Lions fan.

And while the organization discovered a hidden gem in running back Kenneth Gainwell by signing him to a nearly veterans minimum deal last offseason, the team’s MVP and impending free agent might have priced himself out of a return to Pittsburgh, especially if a new head coach brings in their own offensive coordinator.

«There are a few exciting young offensive linemen and some elements on offense, but not enough,» one team source remarked.

The defense is aging in numerous areas, with one AFC executive questioning if Watt’s substantial cap hit — slated at $42 million in each of the next two seasons — will yield diminishing returns as he approaches his 32nd birthday, potentially hindering roster management.

Moreover, according to sources, most Steelers assistant coaches are no longer under contract, which intensifies the uncertainty surrounding the Steelers’ future.

Beyond the roster composition, a new head coach will need to follow in the footsteps of a man who created and sustained the culture of a historic organization for nearly twenty years, one whose mantras adorn walls and are printed on shirts. He will also be tasked with attempting to modernize a conservative franchise that has largely resisted change into one capable of genuinely contending in 2026 and beyond.

Just days after his departure, Tomlin’s influence remains significant over one of the league’s foundational franchises — and it could persist indefinitely.

«Since my childhood, it’s always been Mike Tomlin, Mike Tomlin, Mike Tomlin, and winning and winning and winning,» tight end Smith reflected. «The culture that the city has built, football-wise, is centered around what Mike Tomlin has accomplished — the culture he established, the manner in which he constructed this team, how he’s treated people within the organization, and how deeply he has cared for this franchise.

«He epitomizes what it means to be a Pittsburgh Steeler.»